Stocks suffered a second day of decline to close out the week below the close of August as trading ended on Friday, with the volume of shares changing hands dropped 28 percent and the value falling by 27 percent from Thursday close on the Junior Market on Friday.
Market activity led to 37 securities trading from 38 on Thursday and ended with eight rising, 19 declining and 10, closing unchanged. The Junior Market Index dropped 30.04 points to 3,287.09.
The PE Ratio, that is used to compute appropriate stock values averages 11.3 on Friday, based on ICInsider.com’s 2021-22 earnings forecast.
Trading ended with 4,053,642 shares changing hands for $10,381,943 down from 5,648,917 units at $14,145,296 on Thursday. Future Energy Source led trading with 54.1 percent of total volume after an exchange of 2.19 million shares, followed by Lumber Depot 6.9 percent, with 279,363 units and Jetcon Corporation 6 percent, with 244,099 units.
Trading averaged 109,558 units at $280,593, down from 148,656 at $372,245 on Thursday and average 136,218 units for the month to date at $330,382, compared to 149,370 units at $354,944 on Thursday. August closed with an average of 464,471 units at $1,258,652.
Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator shows two stocks ending with bids higher than their last selling prices and two with lower offers.
At the close, AMG Packaging rose 5 cents to finish the day at $1.65 with an exchange of 2,136 shares, Caribbean Assurance Brokers slipped 5 cents to $1.75 with 13,539 stocks traded, Caribbean Cream shed 30 cents to end at $5.70 with investors switching ownership of 42 stock units. Consolidated Bakeries fell 8 cents to end trading at $1.72 with 1,750 shares changing hands, Elite Diagnostic gained 5 cents to close at $3.02 with a transfer of 5,199 units, Everything Fresh lost 7 cents to settle at 90 cents with an exchange of 6,800 stock units. Fontana slipped 6 cents to $5.89 with 126,320 stocks traded, Future Energy Source dropped 15 cents to $2.05 with 2,193,526 shares passing through the market, General Accident fell 16 cents to $5.40 with 30,000 stock units changing hands. Honey Bun rose 5 cents to $9.25 with a transfer of 2,887 stocks, Jetcon Corporation dropped 8 cents to 91 cents with an exchange of 244,099 shares, KLE Group gained 11 cents to end at $1.13 with 5,833 units traded. Knutsford Express shed 98 cents to close at $7 with investors switching ownership of 12,032 stock units, Lasco Distributors declined by 13 cents to $3.70 with 243,244 shares changing hands, Limners and Bards fell 18 cents to $3.32 with a transfer of 104,501 units. Mailpac Group spiked 15 cents to $3.75 with 130,587 stocks traded, Medical Disposables slipped 5 cents to $4.60 with 332 stock units passing through the market, SSL Venture dropped 15 cents to 62 cents with 20,300 units changing hands and tTech advanced 33 cents to $4.70 with 17,151 shares crossing the exchange.
Prices of securities trading are those for the last transaction of each stock unless otherwise stated.
Is Fesco’s pricing rational?
Investors who bought shares in Future Energy Source in the IPO in April or a few months after are laughing all the way to the bank, with the price providing a gain of 311 percent up to Friday. The recent rally in the stock has moved it from an IPO price of 80 cents to $3.29 at the close on Friday, making it the highest valued Junior Market stock at a PE of 25 times current year’s earnings, with the next closest being, Honey Bun at 18.3.
With just 15 service stations within its network and the planned opening of the Beechwood Avenue station, there is much scope for the company to expand and grow profits in the future, but it seems a bit overdone for Fesco to be priced at a 38 percent premium to the next highest priced stock on the Junior Market.
The company’s latest financial report shows profit surging 55.5 percent to $40 million before taxes for the 2021 June quarter versus $25.7 million in the first quarter of 2020. Profit after taxes rose 66 percent from $24 million. There is no tax charge for the latest quarter, resulting from listing on the Junior Market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange. The tax incentive provides a 10 years tax concession, with no taxes payable for 5 years and at 50 percent of the normal rate for the second 5 years.
A 29.5 percent spike in the volume of fuel sold added 2.9 million litres to volume sales, helping to push revenues for the quarter up 58 percent to $1.9 billion from $1.2 billion in 2020 and much greater than the $1.5 billion generated in March 2021 quarter. Most of the June increase over the March quarter would be due to the increased price of imported fuel, emanating from the upward movement in world oil prices during the period. Sales for the June 2020 quarter, was negatively affected by disruption to business following the outbreak of covid-19 last year.
The first quarter performance is ahead of the opening of the new Fesco Ferry service station on July 15, which is dealer owned and operated.
The Company recorded a gross profit of $55 million, an increase of 63.4 percent over the June 2020 quarter of $34 million.
Operating and administrative expenses for the 2021 first quarter popped 139 percent from $8.6 million to $20.5 million, due mainly to spending in new areas during the quarter, with no cost in 2020. Advertising consumed $2.9 million, directors fees $1.4 million, amortization of right of use assets $867,000, while legal and professional fees rose from $310,000 to $2 million and audit and accounting fees added $1 million, with virtually none in 2020.
Finance Income increased from $1.7 million to $6.4 million, with foreign exchange gains accounting for $4.4 million in the 2021 quarter. Interest cost was minimal at under $1 million in the 2020 and 2021 periods.
Current assets amount to $547 million and current liabilities $210 million, with net current assets of $336 million versus $145 million in 2020. Cash funds amount to $282 million and receivables and amounts due from related parties amount to $250 million.
Shareholders Equity stands at $582 million, up from $231 million at the end of June 2020, reflecting the net proceeds from the IPO earlier this year and an increase in retained earnings. The company outlaid $238 million in work in progress in building out the service station on Beechwood Avenue in Kingston, with $114 million incurred in the June quarter.
RJR drops to 10, Proven & Jetcon join TOP10
The highlights this past week is that after one week back in the ICInsider.com TOP10 list, Dolphin Cove’s price surged from $9.86 to the week’s high of $12.50 for a rise of 27 percent but closed the week at $11.60 for a healthy 18 percent gain for the week.
RJR just held on to the TOP 10 with a gain of 135 percent for the year to date, but the stock that is trading with good volume traded as high as $4.78 during the week.
Proven Investments joins the Main market TOP10 and replaces Scotia Group while Jetcon Corporation price dipped to 91 cents and replaces tTech, with the price rising to $4.79 from $4.40 last week. Elsewhere, Future Energy Source, one of ICInsider.com BUY RATED stocks when the IPO came to market in April, gained 311 percent to date, but with projected earnings of 13 cents per share and the price at $3.29, the PE is a rich 25 times earnings and seems overpriced based on prices of other Junior Market stocks. Radio Jamaica, as previously suggested by ICInsider.com, the directors will be meeting on September 6 to consider a dividend payment.
The charting of the Junior and Main Market indices shows early signs of the markets bouncing from the mild summer correction. We may be seeing early signs of a longer term rebound, with the Main and Junior Markets closing at the highest levels this week since July 23.
Outside the Junior and Main markets TOP10, investors should keep an eye on AMG Packaging and Sterling Investments.
The top three Main Market stocks are Berger Paints, with the potential to gain 273 percent, followed by Guardian Holdings and JMMB Group, with expected gains of 214 to 273 percent for the three, versus last weeks’ 202 to 277 percent.
The top three stocks in the Junior Market are Elite Diagnostic, followed by General Accident and Lasco Financial. All three have the potential to gain between 217percent and 283 percent, compared to 227 and 268 percent last week. Stationery and Office Supplies closed the previous week at $5.75 to sit at number 2 in the Junior Market list enjoyed a bounce in price to $6.50 and moved down to the 8th spot this week.
This past week the average gains projected for the Junior Market dropped from 207 percent to 191 percent and Main Market stocks from 172 percent to 168 percent.
The Junior Market closed the week with an average PE of 11.8 based on ICInsider.com’s 2021-22 earnings and currently trades well below the target of 20 as well as the historical average of 17 for the period to March this year, based on 2020 earnings. The TOP 10 trades at a PE of 7, with a 40 percent discount to the PE of that market and the potential to rise 69 percent to march next year, based on an average PE of 20.
The JSE Main Market ended the week with an overall PE of 15.6, a little distance from the 19 the market ended at in March, suggesting a 12 percent rise at a PE of 19 and 28 percent at a PE of 20 from now to March 2022. The Main Market TOP 10 trades at a PE of 7.7, with a 50 percent discount to that market’s average PE, well off the potential of 20.
The TOP10 stocks are not always the best stocks in the market but are most likely to be the best winners within a fifteen-month period. IC ranked stocks to filter out the big winners, allowing investors to focus on potentially big winners and help to keep out emotional attachments to stocks.
IC TOP10 stocks are likely to deliver the best returns up to March 2022 and ranked in order of potential gains, based on likely increase for each company, taking into account the earnings and PE ratios for the current fiscal year. Expected values will change as stock prices fluctuate and result in weekly movements in and out of the lists. Revisions to earnings per share are ongoing, based on receipt of new information.
Persons who compiled this report may have an interest in securities commented on in this report.
New IPOS expected in October
The initial public offer of shares in Jamaica Fibreglass Products is expected to come to the Jamaican Capital market in October, our source advises, with Spur Tree Spices to come shortly after.
The company produces fiberglass based furniture and beddings, with revenues said to be in the region of $600 million, is expected to raise approximately $250 million for expansion purposes. The prospectus of the Metry Seaga owned company is said to be at an advanced stage of preparation and should be moving through the various stages for approval soon.
Spur Tree Spices, with revenues, said to be just over $1 billion, should also be coming in October, if all goes well, with a view to pull in $250 million. GK Capital are brokers of the two issues that are slated to list on the Junior Market. The prospectus of the company that has been manufacturing seasonings and sauces since 2006 for the local and export markets is also at an advanced stage of readiness, ICInsider.com gathers.
ICInsider.com is informed that the prospectus for one issue is in a draft form currently, so it should be ready to move to the regulators shortly. IPOS are subject to approval, primarily by the Jamaica Stock Exchange and Financial Securities Commission, before the prospectus can be released to the public as such, the exact timing is subject to signing off by them.
One source advised IC Insider.com that there are several potential listing candidates in the Manufacturing sector, with a number of them expressing interest in the listing. Another source advises that there are a number of potential listings in the NCB Capital Markets pipeline. The disruption to business caused by covid-19 is creating delays in some of the issues.
What appears to be a rush to list is a marked departure from the situation that existed before the advent of the Junior Market, with many business owners now seeing the major benefits that listings bring and the usefulness of long term capital.
In the meantime, Sygnus Real Estate Finance IPO that is seeking to sell 207.6 million up sizeable by 38.86 million units to raise a maximum of US$15 million, is extended to Friday, September 10.
Wigton price collapses
Wigton Windfarms’ shares traded below the IPO price of 50 cents on Friday as attempts to shield the price from falling after announcing a drop in revenues is finally giving way to selling pressure. The Wigton syndrome continues to plaque the Jamaica Stock market with irrational behavior of investors to be seen in the prices of many stocks.
Wigton traded nearly 90% of shares on Thursday.
On August 25, investors bought 5 million shares of Future Energy, up to $2.85 and for the next two trading day’s they just over 10 million units up to $3.29, with 15 million shares trading on the 30th at an average of $2.96. The stock is now trading at $2.04, with a PE ratio of 16, to be one of the more highly priced Junior Market stocks. What is happening here, when viewed against stocks with much lower PEs and good growth prospects?
Radio Jamaica another stock that traded as high as $4.65 on August 25, traded on Friday at $3.11 at a PE ratio of 7. Salada Foods continues to trade around the $7 region at a PE ratio of 43 times current year’s earnings. Wigton Windfarms that investors were not informed until late last year that the contract for their number 2 turbine provide for a reduction in rates for the supplying of electricity to JPS, belatedly traded down to 46 cents on Friday with few bids left in the system, and now trades at a PE of 12.5.
The stock market is a wonderful creation that has helped to enrich participants over the years, like any endeavor the more time spent studying and understanding it the better off those investors will be.
There are thousands of new investors in the market brought on by several new listings on the market, with most listings creating good returns in a relatively short time for early investors.
In the past, investors and scholars developed systems and methods to act as a guide to better investment decisions and thus reduce the love or dislike for a stock or other types of investments and thus reduce emotional decisions.
Technical analysis is a very useful tool used in the investment arena that carries coded messages for persons who understand them. They help investors to avoid excessive behavior in markets and telegraph future trends by using past market movements as the base.
The recent price movements for Radio Jamaica and Fesco show them breaking out of a channel that goes back for months, both companies released results that were price movers and both broke out, with the market not fully there as yet as prices moved too far too fast as such prices pulled back.
A few months after Wigton shares were listed in 2019, ICINsider.com wrote a piece to help investors better understand stock market behavior and prevent losses in the market. The piece captioned “Wigton price dreamers” was published in May of 2019. In light of the irrational trading in Fesco and Salada shares, elements of the article are highlighted below.
Salada Foods traded at a all-time high of $18 on Tuesday.
“Buy now, Ride the $3 wave”. That is the advice of one online investor to another, regarding the likely performance of the Wigton Windfarm stock after trading, on the first day of listing at 83 cents with a PE of 14, placing the value in the upper half of the most valued main market stocks. The premium over net asset value another measure of valuation is 291 percent above the net asset value. At $3, the stock would trade at a stunningly high PE ratio of 50 times 2019 and 2020 earnings. The only main market stock close to that valuation is Kingston Wharves (KW) at 35 times 2019 earnings and that is coming down from more than 50 times 2018 earnings when it traded at $85.
Unlike KW, which has less than 10 percent of the shareholding that will trade, amounting to a few million units, Wigton has billion of shares that will trade. The high liquidity of the shares almost ensures that they will not become overvalued.
Most investors who would be big buyers are more professional and are versed in the valuation levels of stocks. Accordingly, they are unlikely to be buying a stock that has doubtful expansion credentials at an inflated value. The most popular valuation tool, the PE ratio does not support a price much higher than $1.20, with EPS of 60 cents per share. A price of $1.20 equates to a high PE ratio of 20. Only a few stocks are valued close to this multiple and many of them have prospects for profits to grow. Wigton has no immediate prospects for growth in earnings, pricing it at 20 times EPS would therefore be unwise. The market will speak but the heavy selling on Friday when it first traded is more in line with the thinking that the top is not far off. Investors who buy shares above the accepted market norm will likely get crushed.
In the investment world staying close to the crowd with pricing is a prudent investment practice that tends to be less costly than trying to predict lofty heights for stocks to reach.
PE ratios are there to give a sense of appropriate values, when investors try to break away from where the bulk of investors place a value of a stock, they usually end up regret the move.