Trading on the Trinidad & Tobago Stock Exchange was dominated by on Monday by Sagicor Financial, accounting for 70 percent of the volume and 68 percent of the value traded. The market closed with 302,101 shares trading, valued at $2,780,408 compared to Friday’s paltry 39,197 shares valued at $1,384,254.
At the close, no stock advanced, 4 declined while 9 were unchanged, resulting from 13 securities changing hands, the same as on Friday.
The Composite Index declined 0.84 points to 1,215.31, the All T&T Index fell 0.09 points to 1,793.22 and the Cross Listed Index dropped 0.22 points to close at 85.44.
IC bid-offer Indicator| The Investor’s Choice bid-offer ended with 4 stocks with bids higher than last selling prices and 3 with lower offers.
Losses| Angostura Holdings lost 1 cent to close at $15, with 470 shares changing hands, Calypso Macro Index Fund 
traded 10 cents lower, to close at a 52 weeks’ low of $21.40 with only 30 shares exchanged, Grace Kennedy closed at $2.85, with a loss of 5 cents trading 29,434 shares and Sagicor Financial closed at $8.90, after losing 9 cents and trading 212,206 shares valued at $1,888,727.
Firm Trades| Clico Investment exchanged 238 shares at $22.50, First Citizens traded 1,915 shares at $31.85, JMMB Group closed at $1.28, with an exchange of 1,493 shares. National Flour Mills closed at $2.30, with 100 shares changing hands, Readymix held firm at $11 exchanging 990 shares, Scotiabank remained at $58, trading 9,740 shares valued at $564,920. Scotia Investments closed at $2.50 while exchanging 41,935 shares,Trinidad Cement closed at $4.20 trading 1,404 shares and Trinidad & Tobago NGL traded 2,146 shares at $21.
Falling prices hit TTSE on Monday
JSE main market jumps – Friday
Carreras closed at a new high of $89 on Friday.
The closing indices in the main market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange closed strongly higher on Friday by more than 2,000 points even as the advance decline ratio was almost one to one. The market closed with 27 securities changing hands including 1 trading in the US dollar market. At the close, 10 stocks advanced and 9 declined.
Trading levels in the main market ended at 3,774,318 units valued at $94,412,872 compared to 2,282,207 units valued at $48,598,384 at the close on Thursday. Trading in the US dollar market accounted for 27,750 units valued at US$7,906.
The All Jamaica Composite Index advanced 2,195.29 points to close at 263,972.73 the JSE Market Index climbed 2,000.15 points to finish at 240,509.05 and the JSE US dollar market index gained 0.45 points to close at 215.54.
IC bid-offer Indicator| At the end of trading in the main and US dollar markets, the Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator reading shows 10 stocks with bids higher than their last selling prices and none with lower offers.
The main market ended trading with an average of 145,166 units valued at $3,631,264 for each security traded, compared to an average of 111,569 units valued at $2,429,919 on Thursday. The average volume and value for the month to date, are 128,368 units and $3,030,592. The average volume and value for May ended at 358,008 units and $9,037,303.
In market activity, Barita Investments traded 10 cents lower to close at$7.10, with an exchange of 82,225 shares, Berger Paints gained 10 cents, closing at $18.64 with trades of 9,642 shares, Cable and Wireless closed at $1.30, trading 541,675 shares while Caribbean Cement exchanged 4,915 shares at $29.99. Carreras jumped $4 to close at a 52 weeks’ high of $89, with 13,837 shares changing hands, Grace Kennedy lost 1 cent to close at $40.99 exchanging 1,141,371 units, Jamaica Broilers closed at $17.90, losing 10 cents with 57,091 shares traded at the same time Jamaica Producers lost 20 cents to close at $16.50, with 82,100 shares traded. Jamaica Stock Exchange gained 19 cents, closing at $7.39 with an exchange of 165,761 shares, JMMB Group closed at $20.50, with gains of 50 cents trading 79,537 units, 
Kingston Properties traded 50 cents lower to close at $11, with 15,277 shares, Kingston Wharves exchanged 15,524 shares at $32, Mayberry Investments lost 5 cents to close at $4.75, with an exchange of 39,790 shares, NCB Financial Group was down 1 cent to $70.99, after exchanging 69,538 shares, 138 Student Living exchanged 2,900 shares at $4.49. PanJam Investment closed at $35, with gains of 50 cents trading 5,955 shares, Portland JSX added 35 cents to close at $10.50, with 1,417 shares changing ownership, Pulse Investments traded 1,000 shares at $18, Radio Jamaica exchanged 7,216 shares at $1.70, Sagicor Group lost 40 cents to close at $34.20, with trades of 179,803 units. Scotia Group closed at $45.90, with gains of $1.91 exchanging 430,372 shares, Seprod closed at $29.52, with a loss of 48 cents trading 1,221 stock units, Sterling Investments closed at $15.50, with 350,890 shares changing hands, Supreme Ventures gained 20 cents to close at $7.20 exchanging 306,881 shares. Proven Investments traded 27,750 ordinary shares at 28 US cents, Jamaica Money Market 7.5% preference share gained 18 cents, closing at $2 with trades of 2,500 units and JMMB Group 7.5% preference share closed at $1.15, with a gain of 5 cents in exchanging 165,880 units.
Trading sinks in Trinidad
Overall volume of stocks trading on the Trinidad & Tobago Stock Exchange on Friday dropped to less than 40,000 units as 13 securities changed hands compared to 12 on Thursday with 1 stock advancing, 3 declining and 9 unchanged.
A total of 39,197 shares were exchanged at a value of $1,384,254 at the close of the market compared to Thursday’s 121,444 shares valued at $942,101.
The Composite Index lost 0.22 points to 1,216.15, the All T&T Index fell 0.44 points to 1,793.31 and the Cross Listed Index closed unchanged at 85.66.
IC bid-offer Indicator| The Investor’s Choice bid-offer ended with 4 stocks with bids higher than last selling prices and 5 with lower offers.
Gains| Angostura Holdings gained 1 cent, closing at $15.01 trading 30 shares.
Losses| Clico Investment lost 1 cent to close at $22.50, with an exchange of 9,586 shares, 
Massy Holdings closed at $51.10, with a loss of 35 cents trading 15,195 shares valued at $776,465 and Point Lisas closed at $4, losing 5 cents in exchanging 100 shares.
Firm Trades| Agostini’s traded 500 shares at $18.51, Ansa McAL closed at $66, trading 50 shares, First Citizens exchanged 3,598 shares at $31.85, Grace Kennedy remained at $2.90 trading 3,000 shares, National Enterprises closed at $10.50, with 1,380 shares changing hands, One Caribbean Media closed trading with 100 shares at $16. Scotiabank held firm at $58, with 1,418 shares changing hands, Trinidad & Tobago NGL traded 3,595 shares at $21 and West Indian Tobacco exchanged 645 shares at $126.40.
JSE main market falls Thursday
The main market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange fell moderately at the closed on Thursday for the first time since for the week with 23 securities changing hands including 3 trading in the US dollar market. At the close, 4 stocks advanced and 8 declined with 2 trading a new highs.
Trading levels in the main market ended at 2,282,207 units valued at $48,598,384 compared to 1,782,575 units valued at $37,905,161 at the close on Wednesday. Trading in the US dollar market accounted for 108,650 units valued at US$35,680.
The All Jamaica Composite Index declined 681.28 points to close at 261,777.44, the JSE Market Index fell 620.72 points to finish at 238,508.90 and the JSE US dollar market index lost 0.59 points to close at 215.09.
IC bid-offer Indicator| At the end of trading in the main and US dollar markets, the Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator reading shows 9 stocks with bids higher than their last selling prices and 1 with a lower offer.
The main market ended trading with an average of 111,569 units valued at $2,429,919 for each security traded, compared to an average of 66,021 units valued at $1,403,895 on Wednesday. The average volume and value for May ended at 358,008 units with an average value of $9,037,303.
In market activity, Cable and Wireless closed at $1.30, with a loss of 4 cents trading 188,217 shares and Caribbean Cement traded 22,002 shares at $29.99. Carreras gained $2 and closed at a 52 weeks’ high of $85, with 13,835 shares changing hands, Grace Kennedy traded 101,889 units at $41, Jamaica Broilers exchanged 10,043 shares at $18, Jamaica Producers traded 29 cents lower to close at $16.70, with 16,329 shares trading. JMMB Group exchanged 157,515 units at $20, Kingston Wharves gained 40 cents to close at $32, with 3,808 shares changing hands, Mayberry Investments traded 11,000 shares at $4.80, NCB Financial Group closed at $71, after exchanging 50,828 shares, 138 Student Living exchanged 10,000 shares at $4.49. PanJam Investment closed at $34.50, with a loss of 40 cents, trading 23,010 shares, Pulse Investments climbed to a 52 weeks’ high of $18, with gains of $3.50 in trading 33,829 shares,
Sagicor Group gained 60 cents to close at $34.60, with an exchange of 144,126 shares, Sagicor Real Estate Fund closed at $10.68, after losing 32 cents with 431,727 units changing hands. Scotia Group closed at $43.99, with a loss of $1.01 in trading 103,901 units, Scotia Investments traded 1,998 shares at $37.85, Seprod exchanged 554,950 shares at $30, Sterling Investments closed at $15.50, with 1,500 shares changing owners, while Supreme Ventures lost 50 cents to close at $7 trading 401,700 shares. Margaritaville Turks closed at 34 US cents exchanging 11,000 units, Proven Investments closed at 28.49 US cents, with an exchange of 92,650 ordinary shares and JMMB Group USD 6% preference share lost 0.01 US cent, closing at US$1.12 with 5,000 units changing hands.
Small volumes dominate TTSE trading – Thursday
Trading on the Trinidad & Tobago Stock Exchange on Thursday was dominated by small trades and resulted in 12 securities changing hands compared to 14 on Wednesday. At the close 1 stock advanced, 3 declined and 8 were unchanged.
A total of 121,444 shares were exchanged at a value of $942,101 compared to Wednesday’s 274,613 shares valued at $2,047,725.
The Composite Index gained 0.12 points to 1,216.37, the All T&T Index rose 0.25 points to 1,793.75 and the Cross Listed Index closed unchanged at 85.66.
IC bid-offer Indicator| The Investor’s Choice bid-offer ended with 3 stocks with bids higher than last selling prices and 4 with lower offers.
Gains| Trinidad & Tobago NGL advanced 25 cents to close at $21, with 155 shares traded.
Losses| L.J. Williams B lost 5 cents to close at 80 cents, with a mere 20 shares changing hands, 
Republic Financial Holdings traded 2 cents lower to close at $101.90, with an exchange of 1,100 shares and Unilever Caribbean closed at $52.60, losing 40 cents in trading 30 shares.
Firm Trades| Angostura Holdings held firm at $15 exchanging 11,000 shares, Ansa McAL closed at $66, with trades of 20 shares and Ansa Merchant Bank traded 494 shares at $40. Clico Investment closed at $22.51 trading 12,514 shares, First Caribbean International exchanged 10,000 shares at $7.75, Grace Kennedy closed at $2.90 with an exchange of 78,125 shares. JMMB Group closed at $1.28, with 21,986 shares changing hands and Trinidad Cement traded 6,000 shares at $4.20.
TTSE rise with soft underbelly
Market activity on the Trinidad & Tobago Stock Exchange on Wednesday resulted in 14 securities changing hands compared to 12 on Monday with 4 stocks rising and 3 declining but IC Insider indicator show more stocks closing with offers that were lower than the last traded price than those with bids being higher.
The market closed with 274,613 shares exchanged for $2,047,725 compared to Monday’s 224,838 shares valued at $1,570,480 as the market was closed for public holiday on Tuesday.
The Composite Index advanced 1.96 points to 1,216.25, the All T&T Index gained 0.05 points to 1,793.50 and the Cross Listed Index was up 0.53 points to close at 85.66.
IC bid-offer Indicator| The Investor’s Choice bid-offer ended with 2 stocks with bids higher than last selling prices and 7 with lower offers.
Gains| Grace Kennedy gained 5 cents to close at $2.90, with 23,186 shares changing hands, Guardian Holdings traded 7 cents higher to close at a $16.10, with 9,297 shares, 
JMMB Group closed at $1.28, with a 1 cent gain trading 38,716 shares and NCB Financial Group added 5 cents, closing at $4, with an exchange of 142,278 shares valued at $569,073.
Losses| Massy Holdings traded 20 cents lower, closing at $51.25 in exchanging 879 shares, National Flour closed 5 cents lower to $2.30, with 1,063 shares trading and Scotiabank closed at $58, losing 1 cent trading 50 shares.
Firm Trades| Angostura Holdings held firm at $15 exchanging 17,500 shares, Clico Investment closed at $22.51, with trades of 21,500 shares valued at $483,965, First Citizens traded 11,448 shares at $31.85 valued at $364.626. National Enterprises exchanged 100 shares at $10.50, Trinidad Cement traded 7,866 shares at $4.20, Trinidad & Tobago NGL closed at $20.75 trading 718 shares and West Indian Tobacco exchanged 12 shares at $126.40.
JSE majors jump again on Wednesday
The main indices of the main market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange surged again on Wednesday pushing them within striking distance from the record high reached recently. At the close 27 securities changed hands in the main market with 3 trading in the US dollar market with 9 stocks advancing and 6 declining.
Trading levels in the main market ended at 1,782,575 units valued at $37,905,161 compared to 7,796,244 units valued at $62,297,173 at the close on Tuesday. Trading in the US dollar market accounted for 37,630 units valued at US$13,624.
The All Jamaica Composite Index advanced 2,152.18 points to close at 262,458.74, the JSE Market Index rose 1,960.88 points to finish at 239,129.62 and the JSE US dollar market index gained 9.71 points to close at 215.66.
IC bid-offer Indicator| At the end of trading in the main and US dollar markets, 
the Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator reading shows 6 stocks with bids higher than their last selling prices and none with lower offers.
The main market ended trading with an average of 66,021 units valued at $1,403,895 for each security traded, compared to an average of 311,850 units valued at $2,491,887 on Tuesday. The average volume and value for the month to date ended at 358,008 units with an average value of $9,037,303 compared with an average of 371,912 units with an average value of $7,355,047 on the previous trading day. The average volume and value for April ended at 382,748 units with an average value of $5,254,387In market activity, Barita Investments closed at $7.20 trading 809 shares,Berger Paints gained 2 cents to close at $18.54 exchanging 1,118 shares, Cable and Wireless closed at $1.34, with trades of 111,000 shares, Caribbean Cement traded 1,879 shares at $29.99. Carreras lost $1 and closed at $83, with 16,045 shares changing hands, Grace Kennedy gained 10 cents to close at $41 trading 72,235 units, Jamaica Broilers exchanged 80,541 shares at $18, Jamaica Producers traded $1.39 cents higher to close at $16.99, with 36,431 shares trading, Jamaica Stock Exchange closed at $7.20, with 7,880 shares changing ownership. JMMB Group advanced $1.15 to $20 exchanging 1,028,499 units, Kingston Wharves lost 40 cents to close at $31.60, with 11,066 shares traded, Mayberry Investments exchanged 10,695 shares at $4.80, with a loss of 70 cents. 
NCB Financial Group closed at $71, with gains of 40 cents after exchanging 29,295 shares, 1834 Investments traded 3,304 shares at $1.40,138 Student Living exchanged 3,772 shares at $4.49. PanJam Investment closed at $34.90, after a loss of 10 cents with 41,600 shares traded, Portland JSX exchanged 600 shares at $10.15, Pulse Investments traded 15,460 shares at $14.50, Radio Jamaica closed at $1.70, while 44,844 shares traded, Sagicor Group exchanged 36,564 shares at $34, Sagicor Real Estate fund closed at $11, with 14,795 units changing hands. Scotia Group jumped $2.50 and closed at $45, in exchanging 93,110 units, Scotia Investments gained $1.35 to close at $37.85 trading 600 shares, Seprod exchanged 15,669 shares at $30, Supreme Ventures added 25 cents to close at $7.50 trading 93,457 shares. Margaritaville Turks closed at 34 US cents exchanging 730 units, Proven Investments traded at 28.50 US cents, with an exchange of 33,500 ordinary shares, JMMB 7.5% preference share lost 18 cents to close at $1.82 trading 8,507 units and JMMB Group USD 6% preference share gained 0.01 US cent, closing at $1.13 with 3,400 units changing hands.
JSE Main market surges
The main market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange enjoyed a big bounce at the close of trading on Tuesday with 25 securities changing hands and 2 trading in the US dollar market. At the close, 7 stocks advanced and 10 declined.
Trading levels in the main market ended at 7,796,244 units valued at $62,297,173 compared to 836,055 units valued at $14,784,987 at the close on Monday. Trading in the US dollar market accounted for 51,155 units valued at US$13,984.
The All Jamaica Composite Index advanced 2,095.53 points to close at 260,306.56 the JSE Market Index rose 1,909.26 points to finish at 237,168.74 and the JSE US dollar market index lost 9.64 points to close at 205.95.
IC bid-offer Indicator| At the end of trading in the main and US dollar markets, the Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator reading shows 8 stocks with bids higher than their last selling prices and 1 with a lower offer.
The main market ended trading with an average of 311,850 units valued at $2,491,887 per security traded, compared to an average of 34,836 units valued at $616,041 on Monday. 
The average volume and value for the month to date ended at 371,912 units with an average value of $7,355,047 compared with an average of 374,915 units and $5,236,889 on the previous trading day. The average volume and value for April ended at 382,748 units with an average value of $5,254,387.
In market activity, Barita Investments closed at $7.20 trading 2,000 shares,Berger Paints closed at $18.52, with a loss of $1.48 exchanging 21,400 shares, Cable and Wireless gained 4 cents to close at $1.34, with 54,006 shares trading, Caribbean Cement added $1.99 cents, closing at $29.99 in exchanging 56,002 shares. Carreras jumped $4 and advanced to $84, with 599 shares changing hands, Grace Kennedy lost 10 cents to close at $40.90 trading 95,341 units, Jamaica Broilers traded 6,774 shares at $18, Jamaica Producers traded 41 cents lower to close at $15.60, while trading 39,000 shares, Jamaica Stock Exchange closed at $7.20, with a loss of 10 cents while exchanging 57,952 shares. JMMB Group slid 95 cents to $18.85 trading 403,790 units, Kingston Properties lost 50 cents to close at $11.50, with 3,006 shares traded, Mayberry Investments exchanged 10,000 shares at $5.50, with gains of 60 cents. NCB Financial Group closed at $70.60, losing 40 cents after exchanging 6,478 shares, 1834 Investments traded 500 shares at $1.40, PanJam Investment closed at $35, with a loss of 50 cents in the trading of 8,800 shares. 
Portland JSX exchanged 1,567 shares at $10.15, Pulse Investments traded 11,400 shares at $14.50, Radio Jamaica closed at $1.70, trading 47,634 shares, Sagicor Group added 50 cents to close at $34 exchanging 990,823 shares, Sagicor Real Estate Fund gained 40 cents, closing at $11, with 114,491 units changing hands. Scotia Group closed at $42.50, with gains of 50 cents exchanging 9,544 units, Supreme Ventures closed at $7.25 trading 4,837 shares. Margaritaville Turks closed at 34 US cents trading 2,500 units, Proven Investments closed at 28.5 US cents, with trades of 48,655 ordinary shares, JMMB 7.5% preference share lost 5 cents to close at $2, with an exchange of 4,799,500 units, JMMB Group 7.5% preference share closed at $1.10 trading 1,000,000 and Proven Investments 8.25% preference share traded 80 cents lower to close at $5.20, with 50,000 units changing owners.
Trading sinks in Jamaican stocks – Monday
Trading in the main market of the Jamaica Stock Exchange closed on Monday with main indices rising as 24 securities changed hands and with 2 trading in the US dollar market. At the close, 8 stocks advanced and 6 declined with very low level of trading.
Trading in the main market ended at 836,055 units valued at $14,784,987 compared to 4,417,748 units valued at $73,092,399 at the close on Friday. Trading in the US dollar market accounted for 6,430 units valued at US$6,926.
The All Jamaica Composite Index advanced 922.05 points to close at 258,211.03, the JSE Market Index rose 840.09 points to finish at 235,259.48 and the JSE US dollar market index closed unchanged at 215.59.
IC bid-offer Indicator| At the end of trading in the main and US dollar markets, the Investor’s Choice bid-offer indicator reading shows 9 stocks with bids higher than their last selling prices and 2 with lower offers.
The main market ended trading with an average of 34,836 units valued at $616,041 per security traded, compared to an average of 152,336 units valued at $2,520,428 on Tuesday. The average volume and value for the month to date ended at 374,915 units with an average value of $5,236,889 compared with an average of 392,814 units with an average value of $5,480,092 on the previous trading day. The average volume and value for April ended at 382,748 units with an average value of $5,254,387.
In market activity, Berger Paints closed at $20, gaining $1 while exchanging 49,814 shares, Cable and Wireless closed at $1.30, with 268,988 shares changing hands, Caribbean Cement traded 25 cents lower to close at $28 with 17,316 shares. Carreras closed at $80, with 10,397 shares changing hands and closed with the bid at $81, Grace Kennedy closed at $41 trading 49,831 units, Jamaica Broilers traded 23,833 shares at $18, Jamaica Producers gained 1 cent to close at $16.01, with trades of 22,355 shares, Jamaica Stock Exchange closed at $7.30, with gains of 30 cents while trading 1,602 shares. JMMB Group lost 20 cents to close at $19.80 with 20,100 units, Kingston Wharves gained $1.50 to close at $32, with 7,444 units trading, Mayberry Investments traded 40,050 shares at $4.90, with a loss of 40 cents. NCB Financial Group closed at $71 after gaining 1 cent in exchanging 61,352 shares, 1834 Investments closed at $1.40, with 25,232 shares changing owners, 
138 Student Living exchanged 43,375 shares at $4.49, PanJam Investment closed at $35.50, losing 12 cents trading 65,096 shares. Pulse Investments traded 10,614 shares at $14.50, Radio Jamaica gained 5 cents to close at $1.70, with trades of 18,582 shares, Sagicor Group added 48 cents to close at $33.50 exchanging 14,500 shares, Sagicor Real Estate Fund lost 20 cents, closing at $10.60, with 9,981 units changing hands. Salada Foods closed at $8.50 trading 4,000 shares, Scotia Group closed at $42, with an exchange of 1,700 units, Sterling Investments closed at $15.50 trading 30,000 shares, Supreme Ventures lost 24 cents to close at $7.25 exchanging 10,893 shares. Proven Investments 8.25% preference share traded 29,000 units and rose 79 cents to $6, Proven Investments ordinary shares closed at 29 US cents, with 330 shares and JMMB Group USD 6% preference share gained 0.01 US cent to close at US$1.12, with 6,100 units changing hands.
The Exuberant 10
The JSE stock traded at an outlandish $13.50 & dropped 47% since.
It is not nice to watch one’s investment lose value while others grow delivering big gains at the same time. Many investors plunge into investments that will result in just that happening, as they err and refuse to let go and reinvest, to recover their loss, from gains elsewhere.
A look back at prices in 2005, reveals shocking results of costly ill-timed investments. In June 2005, investors in a bout of excess exuberance, pushed Mayberry Investments to $8.40 from a listed price of $5.05, weeks after it listed on the Jamaica Stock Exchange, 12 years later it is still to reach back to that level. That is a huge blow to investors who held on to the shares from then.
The sad thing is that many investors who wanted to sell could not, as attempts were made to control the price from a big drop as selling started to overwhelm buying a few days after nearly 40 million shares were traded around the $7-8 level. Mayberry is an outstanding example of investors making huge errors based on inadequate information and paying dearly for it.
But Mayberry’s stock is not the only one that investors underwent a long period of suffering from, they have a number of top notch companies as their friends that that performed poorly until fairly recently. Scotia Group was pushed to $33.50 in March 2005 based on results that were not sustainable as the bank benefited by a poor decision of the Central Bank to push interest rates on CDS paying interest at elevated levels for about two to three years. The banks of course made a killing when rates fell back. Added to that, Scotia effected a stock split that sent the stock flying.
Well it was not until late 2016 that the price exceeded the 2005 high. JMMB Group’s shareholders saw the price of the stock peaking at $22 in April 2004 only to see it fall away and not getting back to that level until recently this year. That is not great for a stock that is not a great dividend payer.
Grace Kennedy hit a high of $123 (Now $41 after stock split in 2016), in January 2005, it has taken nearly 12 years to recover the loss and it has still not delivered much more in gains since its full recovery.
Markets tend to repeat past behaviors, over and over but sometimes they take a break from the norm. PE ratios are the end product of investors’ perception of values for stocks. There are other measures but the PE is the most widely used. When PEs are pushed well beyond where the majority of investors thing the value ought to be, they induce added buying or selling. Investors who buy when the market has pushed valuation well above what is considered the norm, usually pay a steep price for so doing. The 2005 examples are cases in point. An accepted concept is that the PE ratio should be line with profit growth. One year’s growth cannot be used by itself but investors have to try and determine that themselves.
Most of the stocks in the IC Insider’s Exuberant 10, were pushed in 2017 by excessive enthusiasm and in some cases wrong information. Stock splits helped to fuel some of the excess as well. The attached table shows the stocks that were pushed well above their appropriate values and the levels of correction since. Some may fall even more than their latest price as they can be considered overvalued based on known earnings for the current period. A few that are not on the list could see a decent fall as well, included in this latter list are Knutsford Express and Kingston Properties.
